Talking about college yesterday, preparing for my little sister to go to college and listening to a question on FreelanceSwitch got me thinking: does one have to go to college or extended learning to become a successful designer or developer?
Personally I can argue on both sides. On one side, I learned an invaluable amount of information from my mentor and become a much better designer because of it. It even affects the way I code and organize the sites I do. However on the other side, I have a $30,000 student loan bill for a design education and I’m not doing any design work.
College was something I regret mostly because I didn’t take advantage of it. Most people say you go to college for the experience, not for the education, but I think its for both. I missed out on the experience portion, mainly because I never wanted to be there, and I regret that today.
So do you need to go to college to be a successful web developer or designer?
The pros
- You’ll learn the basic fundamentals of design or development, including the history of how they got started. Most self-taught designers/devs are lacking in the fundamentals and it sometimes shows.
- You’ll get real critiques that you can’t always get online. Believe me, the professors are NOT afraid to tell you that your work sucks.
- Depending on the school you go to, you’ll gain valuable contacts that you can use later on to get your first job.
- It gives you the time you need to really learn. You’re not jumping feet first into pleasing clients, so you get to take the time to learn proper design techniques, the why’s of why it’s done and semantics in coding.
- The experience is awesome, the games, the community, everything.
The cons
- Unless you have a scholarship, it can be very expensive.
- Even if you have a full scholarship, it can still be very expensive when you’re young and stupid and spend loans you don’t need on crap (yea that was me.)
- A lot of traditional schools teach outdated methods. (Has anyone heard of the world wide web??). We spent SEVERAL semester long classes on how to properly prepare a print portfolio…..when was the last time anyone has asked for a printed portfolio? I know some pretty large studios with big name clients and none of them ask their hires for anything but an online portfolio.
- It takes time, which you may not have if you’re an older adult looking to go back to college.
- No one cares. Seriously. I’ve never been asked or required to have a degree. Your portfolio always speaks for itself.
So is it right for you?
All in all, I think you should go to school if you can when you’re fresh out of high school. It’s something to fall back on if what you really want to do in life doesn’t pan out (most places will accept a hire with any kind of BA) and it’s a great learning experience that you really can’t get from books or the web.
If you’re older and already accomplished, I wouldn’t do it unless it’s some kind of personal life goal. For example, I was thinking for a while about a year ago that I wanted to go back to school and get a degree in web development. But I realized why – I wanted to go back and “experience” college since all I did the first time was go to class and go home. Definitely not a reason to spend another $30,000 on.
Your thoughts
What are your thoughts on college?
(p.s the photo is of my little sister graduating high school a month ago!)